Yoda: He loved him in a hating way. If they thought it was a secret to Vader, they did a bad job hiding it since Anakin and Luke have the same last name. about there still being good in Darth Vader ultimately causing him It’s clear that Lucas had no idea that Luke was Vader’s son when he filmed “Star Wars” (no number needed). shows that deep thinking not Yoda’s forte it was. They have a touchy moment and Vader is clearly in the hurt locker. Luke finally brought him back from the Dark Side of the Force, but it was too little too late. Why would Yoda(and perhaps Obi-Wan) think it is unexpected that Vader would tell Luke? Kenobi is aware of the fact that Luke will witness Vader killing him while he is clearly in a pose of surrender, and he believes this will motivate Luke to become a Jedi Master and a match for Vader. because Luke was right, he still had good in him. I thought Vader was a robot too. He also said In the core-timeline of Star Wars, Luke Skywalker almost died from exposure while stationed on the ice world of Hoth.However, Han Solo used a tauntaun as a makeshift shelter for his friend, saving his life. Nowadays, it seems that “Luke, I am your father” is the one thing that everyone does know going into the Star Wars movies for the first time. Luke Skywalker star Mark Hamill, 69, tweeted: “So sad to hear David Prowse has passed. Darth Vader is a fictional character in the Star Wars franchise. He wants Darth Vader to ... anything we’ve seen before. The white side? Yoda might even have expected that Luke would learn that Vader was his father and turn to the Dark Side - but then Luke wouldn’t be coming back to Yoda with questions. What was Obi Wan right about. Unexpected! A conversation like Ren and Han was much more likely. Before he became Darth Vader, he was just a regular guy named Anakin Skywalker.While regular might be something of a stretch, he’s much more of a human than he ever was as Darth Vader. This may be a trick question for some but Luke did not like Darth Vader. Before he died, he turned back to the good side My take: they wanted Luke more trained in the bright side (what is the opposite of the dark side? Then he throws the Emperor overboard and Luke runs to his side. In contrast, Vader was able to sense his personal connection to Luke Skywalker almost immediately. Luke took a lot more of the Emperor's force lightning blast than Vader did and he was fine. Vader clearly knew sometime before ESB at least. Why did Yoda think Darth Vader would not tell Luke? The revelation that Darth Vader was Anakin Skywalker, Luke’s father, came as a big surprise to those of use who watched The Empire Strikes Back in theaters when it originally came out. Before the final confrontation, Minch has Luke test himself against a simulation of Vader, who tempts Luke with what the Dark Side can offer: Darth: You”re in love with Leia. vader was given a "similar" choice moment where he could "save" all he loved by giving himself over to the dark side, and this was lukes moment. The unexpected situation of Luke and Vader meeting, talking, and then Vader not killing Luke and Luke still managing to escape was pretty unexpected - for good reason. He expected that Luke would kill Vader before the subject came up, or that Vader would kill Luke, or that they’d battle and Luke would escape before conversation could occur. I think we all know all this. As the villain of the original Star Wars trilogy, he captivated audiences with his iconic look, voice, and ruthlessness. So Obi's comment foreshadows at least two major plot developments - his post-death ability to tutor Luke in the ways of the force, and Luke's increased interest in the destruction of the Empire/Vader. Eh, not really. How long will the footprints on the moon last? However, he fully assumed the identity of Darth Vader after he was told that Padme and his child died (even though THEY didn't) Some could say that Darth Vader never really "killed" Anakin and that Anakin … Oh, I agree with that. Is there a way to search all eBay sites for different countries at once? The Emperor was torturing Luke, he used his full strength on Vader. Ya’ll are reaching. I have aggressively argued that he did not as it was only a momentary realisation of his errors and could have been a feign attempt at gaining some form of redemption. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled. In his final moments before dying, Darth Vader asks his son, Luke, to remove his helmet so he may look upon his son one time with his own eyes. It’s just that some find the Doylist perspective less fun and interesting. There’s no way around it. Darth Vader had plenty of experience with surviving horrific wounds and injuries. In some cases, like the video games, his lack of this power is conspicuous in its absence. Yoda might even have expected that Luke would learn that Vader was his father and turn to the Dark Side - but then Luke wouldn’t be coming back to Yoda with questions. David Prowse, who played Darth Vader in the original “Star Wars” trilogy, was suffering from the coronavirus before dying Sunday at age 85, his daughter said in a report. Yoda never expected to that he’d face a Luke who had learned from Vader about his (Luke’s) parentage. Sure, he was a force ghost with Obi-Wan Kenobi and Yoda, but did anyone forgive him? Darth Vader had no such peace at the end of things. At that point, he became Palpatine's apprentice, Darth Vader. New Answer 12-28-10: When Anakin (Darth Vader) was dying he told Luke that he was right. When that First of all, it's crucial to note that there was always an element of mystery in the past of both Darth Vader and the Emperor. before he would confront Vader, but Vader pushed upon the timetable. He wanted a family. That is why we see There had to have be plenty of dependable families (like the Organas) with whom baby Luke could have been safely left, discreetly guarded by Obi-Wan, both under assumed names. Luke doesn't want to take his helmet off cause he thinks it will kill him and Vader says 'nothing can stop that now' So, what killed him? The unexpected situation of Luke and Vader meeting, talking, and then Vader not killing Luke and Luke still managing to escape was pretty unexpected - for good reason. The character is a primary antagonist in the original trilogy and a primary protagonist in the prequel trilogy. The Bristol-born star — also road safety superhero The Green Cross Man — had been in a London hospital for two weeks with Covid. When Darth Vader-Anakin was dying he told Luke that Obi Wan was right. During the Battle of Endor in 4 ABY, a climactic engagement of the Galactic Civil War between the Galactic Empire and the Alliance to Restore the Republic, the Dark Lord of the Sith Darth Vader and his son, Luke Skywalker, faced one another in a final lightsaber duel aboard the second Death Star, a battle station capable of destroying an entire planet. What was Obi Wan right about? The shiny side?) Vader, as a clever strategist, is doing everything he can to get into the head of young Luke. Even if you assume that Vader only had, say, a 1% chance of looking in the obvious place, we’re talking a galaxy of a million planets. He said that obi wan was right because he did turn evil. I agree. And I didn't want to believe he was Luke's father, but deep down I knew he was telling the truth. It’s a coincidence in-movie that the son of someone killed by Vader is nearby when Leia sends a message to Kenobi (Vader kills a lot of people) and a coincidence external to the movie that “Vader” happens to mean “father” in Dutch. There’s no way around it. He expected that Luke would kill Vader before the subject came up, or that Vader would kill Luke, or that they’d battle and Luke would escape before conversation could occur.