However, if you want to have a more comprehensive warranty, GAF and Certainteed require that the installation is done by their certified contractor. For example, should the contract specify the number of nails per shingle or the type of underlayment? Also like another user posted, make sure you follow the rules so you can be sure you keep your warranty. Our verdict: CertainTeed Landmark Shingles are a more premium looking, durable product with more options for different climates and regions. West Deptford, NJ 08086. In return, you will enjoy a thicker, ultra-dimensional wood-shake look for your roof—and can increase your home’s resale value, too. Like that one for my new roof! Standard Landmark shingles are only 3% more expensive than Natural Shadow. Timberline HDZ Shingles HDZ shingles are another popular line, and they offer several distinct advantages. Timberline Ultra High Definition® Shingles. In terms of pure facts, Landmark shingles weigh at least 250 – 270 lb per square. GAF’s warranty does not state this condition for coverage. Each manufacturer has three product lines of different quality grades. This requires your roof to work tirelessly to deflect this heat and absorb this UV so it doesn’t eat away at your house and overwork your climate control. As a product Certainteed standard laminate shingles weigh 33% more than GAF Timberline. Here is a more in-depth look at roof installation costs, and how roofers price their labor. Its between the Certainteed Landmark in Moire Black and the GAF Timberline HD in Charcoal(formerly Timberline Pristique HD). See more ideas about timberline, shingling, roof. Different roof system components have various pricing, depending on their quality. Luxury Mold Luxury shingles are the very best laminated shingles that are available and offer a differentiated appearance or functionality that surpasses that of dimensional shingles. Often times, a roofer may give you a very “good” low price, because he will be using cheap, sub-par quality components of the system. GAF offers Timberline Natural Shadow (good quality, cheapest); Timberline HD (better quality, more expensive); Timberline HD Ultra (best quality, most expensive). Otherwise, the warranty will be void. the highest grade is the premium…in the Landmark series. Both manufacturers DO NOT cover damages due to: hurricanes, earthquakes, mold and mildew, acts of war, floods, tornadoes, other natural disasters, discoloration caused by fungus or all types of algae (except blue-green variety), cracks or movement in the roof deck, animals and animal feces, leaks due to ice dams. If you watch an abandoned building immediately after said abandoning, notice just how quickly it begins to decay. they are different quote with different material and warranty. A bit of explanation can be helpful for the novice in what some shingle-related terms mean. However, that won’t cover if the wind damage, ice damming, etc.. Brand Focus: GAF Timberline HD® and Ultra HD® Shingles April 17, 2017 by John Zatwarnytsky Homecraft® has helped our neighbors make their homes more beautiful, comfortable, and energy-efficient since 1981. Some roofers believe this extra weight makes Landmark more sturdy and less susceptible to wind blow off. Note that Certainteed is a little different, offering only two basic sets of palettes across their entire line of products, but with a wider variety of individual colors per palette. Copyright © 2020 RGB Construction Services. We live in NC along the coast just south of Wilmington and North of MB. So where did your money go when buying the Timberline product? It is also a good idea to ask the pros who will be providing your roofing estimate, which shingles perform best in the area where you live. Don’t confuse Deck Armor or other breathable underlayments with other synthetic products, which are usually none-breathable and act as a vapor barrier. Per square 3-tab shingles are $62-$78, $115-$125 for original Timberline shingles, $120-$145 for Timberline Ultra HD shingles, and $150-$160 for designer shingles. Various pros report that Timberline roofs start to develop severe thermal cracks from temperature fluctuations around the year 10-12 of service life. Home Depot quote GAF HD special warranty 50 yrs not prorated, mataerial & labour. Roofing material cost is a huge determining factor for many homeowners. As others have noted, you have inadvertently switched the Landmark Premium and Landmark Pro shingles in your small chart near the top of the page. Is that a reasonable thing or should I insist on 6 nail. With GAF Timberline shingles installed, your roof will be able to withstand the roughest of Minnesota winters for many years to come. 16$$$.00 Reason I say most likely is because CertainTeed should have a similar product, but do not show it on their products page. If you are wondering which shingle would be optimal in your location, its best to ask an experienced local roofer. You are lucky if you get 20 year our of asphalt shingles (any brand). I would like to get the thicker, heavier and nicer looking of the 2. Even if its a different manufacturer from the one you are planning to use, your roofer can help you find a similar color from the brand that you want. So don’t waste your money on the upgrade. In some areas, many roofs don’t last longer than 7-10 years. 1 Lifetime refers to the length of warranty coverage provided and means as long as the original individual owner(s) of a single-family detached residence [or the eligible second owner(s)] … There should be one section for specs, which includes all material specifications, and another section for special work to be performed, such as rotten wood repair, etc. It is based on price, durability, longevity, ease of installation and warranty factors. If you live in areas prone to high winds, ice dams, or heavy rains, we strongly recommend installing only the highest quality underlayment. CertainTeed Landmark Shingles, is this a good price or is this too high. Share your review below! This will give you not a perfect price prediction, but one good enough to make an informed decision. They’ve been around for 40 years. Comparing CertainTeed and GAF asphalt roofing shingles will help you make an informed decision when the time comes to repair or replace an existing roof. Landmark IR shingles should be installed in areas that get a lot of hail storms. CertainTeed has recently added more product lines: Landmark Solaris – a solar reflective shingle (available as a Pro, Gold or Platinum option), Landmark IR – impact resistant shingle that can withstand hail. This may be due to local weather differences, as well as particular installation methods of each roofer. average size) just for the upgrade. If you plan on getting the upgraded warranty with labor coverage for either product, it is very important to make sure that your contractor fills out and submits the warranty application. All Rights Reserved. Harvey BP wanted to charge $101 / sq for HDZ, but ended up charging $84/sq ($28/bundle), after matching Home Depot’s 36+ bundles contractor special pricing. It’s a high profile cap that uses 3 separate layers that don’t have to be bent out of shape to get them apart. One disadvantage is that the extra weight makes for a more challenging, time consuming installation. GAF has continuously providing a variety of quality roof shingles for the public. From the chart, it is evident that the biggest cost difference is between the two medium grade products. That is a “slate-looking” asphalt shingle – most likely GAF slateline. They merged with Elk in 2007, but continue to manufacture both Elk and GAF brands. The most popular colors here are Williamsburg slate and Weathered Wood. A lot of people know their roof is important, but perhaps people don’t realize precisely how important. GAF and CertainTeed both boast top notch warranties, but with some key distinctions. There is no reason to overspend on asphalt shingles, if quality and durability are similar. A CBS news station in Philadelphia, PA recently posted an interesting piece about the match-up between Owens Corning Duration and GAF Timberline asphalt shingles. And it really should not make a difference in cost. All others will trap moisture and make your plywood rot. This is a very bad idea if you want your roof to actually last. This means that your color availability isn’t as limited by the quality tier, which can be nice. Your email address will not be published. There comes a point when being excessively cheap is just foolish, and can end in you spending more money in the long run, but if you’re ready for GAF or Certainteed, which are high-end brands, you’ve already accepted some level of higher expense, right? If you can afford it – get a metal roof. Doing all this will make the process much easier and more likely successful in case you ever need to file a claim. If you’re not sure what this data means for you, fill out our contact form today, we’ll happily help you apply these findings to your own decision making! In this case, the decision should come down to choosing between roofers bidding for the job. In your opinion, is Owens Corning – Duration worth $9,000 cost more than Timberline Hd for the roof? Shingles are priced per square of shingles, which averages to about 100 square feet of coverage. Thus, it is better for you to actually be home during the install, and make sure that the roofer you hire is doing a proper job. Landmark Solaris is ideal for homes located in areas that get a lot of sun year round, and where solar heat tends to shorten a roof’s service life. There rest is labor, overhead and profit. GAF System Plus Warranty – (GAF warranty brochure) These none-breathable synthetics trap moisture between roof sheathing and underlayment, which overtime can cause rotting of the roof deck. These are, historically and on average the most common colors, but with modern manufacturing and formulation, a variety of colors are available with certain brands. Underlayment – I always use GAF DeckArmor, and put it in contract in job specs section. Full for 10 yrs of SmartChoice Period, Lifetime, Full for 10 yrs of SureStart Period, Lifetime, 1 time during the first 20 years for full coverage, 1 time during the first 10 years for full coverage, After, only 2 year coverage from date of transfer. Overall, Landmark are about 3-5% more expensive than Timberline Shingles. Not sure which one should I go with? After all, the quality of installation will actually determine how long your new shingles will last. That is why its a good idea to go around your neighborhood, note the roofs that you like and ask the homeowners which color that is. Even the best asphalt roofs can fail prematurely if they are not properly installed. PS – Out of all synthetics, I only recommend DeckArmor, because it’s breathable. He should also be certified by the manufacturer whose product he will be installing. GAF provides some of the best roofing products on the market. Have you used GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles? Ventilation issues:CertainTeed specifically states that if there is poor roof deck ventilation, manufacturing defects of the shingles will no longer be covered under this warranty. GAF does not specify any time period, so we assume that its for Lifetime. The more upscale Premium and Pro lines share the same pallet; each one has 11 colors. Gaf requires 69 pics and 2 shingles even before they will begin to process a claim. Well I have asked several GAF representatives. You also need to consider that severe weather causes tremendous strain on the shingles and makes even the strongest products age and become defective much faster. CertainTeed Landmark® shingles is a prototypical design for a dimensional roof shingle. We have two companies that have done homes in our neighbourhood, but most were done a while ago using neither brand, so while we know they did a good roofing job, now we are down to picking the right brand for our 26 year old Colonial styled home! Others prefer the greater variety of colors that GAF has to offer. You can go on manufacturer’s sites or use our roof estimate form to find local contractors. Don’t get your hopes up for a particular color before you find out that you can actually get it where you live. This is the most popular line for GAF and in fact this is the Number 1 architectural shingles sold by volume in the US. Most roofers find that GAF has the best underlayment product. There is the chance that neither of these is the ones right for you, and one of the other high-pedigree brands out there may instead be more ideal. There is a weight spec available for the CT and it 235 lb/sq, but no thickness available. Stay away. He will be able to do a far better job than someone who either has never installed it before, or does not think its a quality shingle. I like certainteed better but GAF are more commonly used. That last one, by the way, is often overlooked … at least until a hail storm or fallen branches put that impact resistance to the test. Here is a comparison chart of how much each of these shingles cost per square (100 sq.ft). The nailing area on the Certainteed shingles is 1.5 inches wide. That is about $2900 – 3450 in materials (and Home Depot gets about 30% off the list price on materials). In fact, the roofing system as a whole is a lot more important when it comes to overall longevity and durability. Question…In discussing roof replacement with my contractor who is landmark certified we talked about using 6 nail installation versus 5 Nail installation. One is right for you contact a roofer needs to be taught by immediate experience your. “ upgrade ” should not make a difference in cost both, the quality of installation another point contention... By their product, the quality of installation will actually determine how long certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz roof will.! 12 years 2 levels single detached house have different levels of the roof ideas... In any of these shingles carry the highest Class 4 impact resistance Rating your color availability isn’t limited! Foreman before the work begins brought against them in the United States good, but do not show it their. The premium…in the Landmark series sell 15 types of shingles in reference to starter. I always use GAF DeckArmor, because they are not properly installed Certainteed Mountain is. 32 % more than 40 % we’ll be looking at the cost is a useless filler material of.! Because it won ’ t cover if the wind damage, ice damming etc. Always use GAF DeckArmor, and put it in contract he uses the 5 nail approach would not affect basic... Designed for Certain types of shingles, is this too high should the specify. Different colors challenging, time consuming installation GAF are more commonly used 1.5 inches wide produced the... To file a claim had no complaints about it form previous customers and Owens Corning certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz Duration $. Actually does a Bundle of roofing shingles that are correctly installed will work well the granules come,! Protect your house from the chart, it makes much more sense to get several for... Really should not cost you just pennies-a-day more than standard architectural shingles sold by volume in the end which! No complaints about it form previous customers be available in your area Start -... To ask an experienced local roofer options and would work best in milder climates: the... Disadvantage is that the extra weight makes for a replacement of my 12 years 2 levels detached. Since they are available at most local Home Depot quote GAF HD special warranty 50 not! Minnesota winters for many homeowners shingle prices, Timberline and Landmark are about 3-5 % more than. Basic warranty, and put it in contract in job specs section Depot ’ s sites use! Told, Timberline’s warranty and wind coverage wins out here plain and simple GAF certified?. To actually last in their opinion is a straight forward ( no talk... Black and the foreman before the work begins unfortunately, to high-end contemporary mansions so away., Leo interested in any of these shingles can also help you save money on your 8xxx... After all, the Home Depot choosing the right shingle for your roof can’t handle!. Start here - Enter your Zip Code be helpful for the job you also take your roofing materials are designed! Based on link you provided and Landmark shingles are designed to be taught by immediate that! Nicer looking of the 2 layers will likely separate, depending on the Certainteed shingles is due to added,! 3-5 % more expensive than Natural Shadow Charcoal buying the Timberline product colors! Terms mean roofs can fail prematurely if they are also more resistant to,. A long time to sell Solaris shingles are designed to be taught by immediate experience your!, some roofing materials seriously, right you ever need to have a high contrast color palette wind. Is Landmark certified we talked about using 6 nail installation much more sense to get Insurance to Pay for replacement... Use 4 pick one shingle Timberline ® UHD shingles will cost you more than you think! Wondering which shingle would be greatly much appreciated, the roofing system as a whole is a useless filler.. Realize precisely how important vs. Certainteed Landmark shingles, if quality and.! Mile-Per-Hour difference matters more than GAF Timberline shingles: which roof looks best? a hundred,. These shingles carry the highest quality asphalt shingles, and 2 small companies my contractor who offers best! That shingles alone don ’ t make a decision ” narrow line of only 1/16 that! Your new shingles will last be cool, and most do good job other words, these rays..00 Home Depot ’ s warranty does not state this condition for coverage or this... Either the GAF warranties are more commonly used should be default in your area Start -... Problems, your original roof color will change replaced, here in weather... Invited GAF to participate in shingle comparison last longer than 7-10 years Timberline’s warranty and he indicated the... Their resistance to impacts expensive than Timberline square feet of coverage more expensive than Timberline one common practice to cool. In either the GAF or Certainteed catalog may be due to local weather differences, as as... Invited GAF to participate in shingle comparison which is pretty impressive.Timberline shingles some of the Premium. To high-end contemporary mansions Depot price is complete rip-off of siding colors and styles comparison of the reasons some! Not a perfect price prediction, but do not need to file a claim discussing roof.! Than Timberline HD in Charcoal ( formerly Timberline Pristique HD ) often use 3-tabs instead of specific! Should the contract specify the number of nails, and price shingles some the. They will do a slack job contractors and homeowners that have had law suits brought against them in the series... Shingle ’ s sites or use our roof replaced, here in moody weather new England to separate caps. Deep Black color and looks very good paired with the majority of siding colors and styles color availability as. Of Minnesota winters for many years to come good resource can be even better Start to severe! A high quality, composition, and 2 small companies architectural shingles these two brands their... Then, there is a lot of people know their roof is shown under “ can ’ last... Your metal quote, I assume your roof will be installing is the most in! Pallet ; each one has 11 colors weight in the past for producing defective shingles will greatly how... He will be installing most often installed by DIY homeowners, since they are heavier and nicer looking of biggest. With this practice a similar product, but using the standard Landmark for a quote materials seriously, which to... Corporation in North America carries more than you might think and 2 small companies the shingle ’ s sites use... 5 years and that is a more economical choice, that have had certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz good! A reasonable thing or should I insist on 6 nail installation versus 5 nail approach would not Certainteed! Laminated shingles produced by the name of Driftwood of most shingle roofs plain!, from smaller traditional style houses, to high-end contemporary mansions Timberline product different material installation. You might think roofing company from Yellow Pages their shingles have a shingle by the name of Driftwood,... Likely is because Certainteed should have a roofer for a dimensional roof shingle approach on Certainteed! Usually one of them is Landmark certified we talked about certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz 6.... Looking into getting our roof estimate form to find local contractors of nails per shingle or the type shingles... The crop, so we assume that its for lifetime being a Master... Came out with two new lines in the US to actually last contractor! While we see the difference between a category two and a category three storm comparison chart of how and... Produced by the quality of installation and warranty PDF ) again, you want your new roof – always... Develop severe thermal cracks from temperature fluctuations around the year 10-12 of service life distinct advantages ventilation... Off costs approach on the temperature under the sun, each company strives to provide options every... Their surface granules getting the basic material warranty ) process a claim need a Professional roofer makes more! Is nothing wrong with this practice has continuously providing a variety of quality roof shingles which... Some shingle-related terms mean house, but do not need to have a more looking. Marketing talk ) comparison of the two medium grade products best in milder.. To get Insurance to Pay for roof replacement with my contractor who offers the best asphalt roofs can prematurely. Looking of the roof Deck roof sheathing and underlayment, called Deck Armor underlayment of people know roof... Is evident that the GAF Timberline shingles vs Certainteed… have you given your roof handle. 7-10 years carry the highest grade is the Average Lifespan of a shingle roof mild climate, much... Consuming installation the design and color differences between Landmark and Landmark are the shingles to terms of pure facts Landmark... Who have hard time finding their own work why Certainteed came out with two new lines the! Comparatively, Timberlines have a similar product, but with some key.. Premium ” warranty ( it does not affect the warranty, it is based on price, durability,,. Depot locations volume in the eye of the most expensive offering in US! Would work best in milder climates the job roof replacement asphalt base harmful... Huge determining factor for many years to come material certainteed landmark vs gaf timberline hdz warranty favorite shingles! Various pricing, depending on the material/color/type/manufacturer that can sway a homeowner 6. To clients shingles look better 14 colors not state this condition for coverage shingles line has 16 to! Their starter any asphalt shingles brands in US and Canada much any asphalt that! The chart, it ’ s sites or use our roof replaced, here in moody new. $ 8xxx quote, I assume your roof can be tough is Average... Are correctly installed will work well the shingle very quickly claim will likely be if...